Casa Di Luigi in Rolling Meadows: Our Date Night Review, What We Ordered and Prices

The Casa Di Luigi building at night on New Wilke Road in Rolling Meadows, with an orange gable, a round Casa Di Luigi sign and string lights over the enclosed patio.

Updated November 2026. A Friday date night for two at Casa Di Luigi in Rolling Meadows, without the kids. The bill is at the bottom.

Friday night, Vika and I wanted to do something different. It came down to Italian or seafood, and Italian won. We also wanted a place we had never been to, so the pick came from a blind Google search: Italian restaurants within about a 20 minute drive, with reviews above 4.5. That was the whole system. Neither of us spent much time on the menu before we went. We were mostly going in blind.

That is how we ended up at Casa Di Luigi, an Italian restaurant on New Wilke Road in Rolling Meadows that has only been around for a few years. And here is the honest version up front: we didn’t walk out of there in the same place. I thought it was decent and tasty, and I would go again. Vika liked parts of it, but she doesn’t see herself rushing back. Both of us loved the cocktails and the fried burrata. Where we split was the entrees.

A small place that used to be something else

The building used to be a different restaurant a while ago, something closer to a fast food spot, and you can kind of still tell. They painted the walls a warm orange, hung prints of the Italian coastline, and put up shelves of wine and spirits by the door. It works, but if I’m honest, the room itself didn’t do much for either of us. It’s fine. It isn’t a room you walk into and think, wow, date night.

The enclosed front patio at Casa Di Luigi with metal tables and chairs, string lights, hanging vines and a green hedge wall.

Out front there is an enclosed patio with string lights and vines. If we had been sitting out there, I could see myself saying it was cute. It does look out onto the parking lot, but then again, so does almost every restaurant in the suburbs.

We sat inside. We got there early on a Friday evening, and it was quiet when we walked in.

What did stand out was our waitress. She was extremely nice, very welcoming and warm, and that set a good tone for the night.

The cocktails were the easy win

We started with cocktails. I had a Negroni, Vika had an old fashioned, and there were no complaints from either side of the table.

My Negroni came with the right ice and tasted exactly the way a Negroni should taste. It was great. Vika said her old fashioned was a pretty generous pour compared to a lot of restaurants. It wasn’t earth shattering, but she had zero complaints about it. The one thing I noticed is that they made her old fashioned with regular ice cubes. It was her drink, I didn’t even taste it, and she was happy with it, so take that for what it’s worth.

With dinner I had a glass of the Cannonball Merlot, and it was just okay. I wasn’t about to send it back, but it didn’t add anything to the meal either. Vika had one sip and thought it was fine. We have had better wine.

The house focaccia and hummus

A plate of hummus topped with olive oil, cheese and pepper next to a plate of house made focaccia with fried onions at Casa Di Luigi.

They told us they make everything in house, the bread and the focaccia included. Before we ordered, they brought out a plate of their focaccia with fried onions baked in, along with hummus topped with olive oil.

We both liked it. The focaccia was good, the hummus was really tasty, and the whole combination worked. It was heavy, with a lot of oil, but you’re eating bread with olive oil at an Italian restaurant. That is kind of the point.

The crispy fried burrata was the dish we would order again

Two breaded, crispy fried burrata balls in an orange spicy tomato sauce with toasted bread slices on an oval plate at Casa Di Luigi.

For an appetizer we ordered the crispy fried burrata, which comes in a spicy tomato sauce with toasted bread on the side. Neither of us had ever had fried burrata before, and it was delicious.

The sauce is what got me. It reminded me of the stuffed peppers we make at home, when you mix sour cream into the sauce. It had the slightest kick to it.

The menu flags it as spicy. Neither of us found it spicy at all, but Vika and I will happily eat pure spice, so I think a lot of people would feel that kick more than we did. Cut into it and the cheese runs everywhere, which is exactly what you want.

One thing we noticed reading the menu: there is very little grilled seafood on it, and what there is shows up in the entrees. The seafood appetizers we saw were all fried. I’m not sure which region of Italy the menu leans toward, but it’s clearly not the one where you get grilled seafood.

My Salmone alla Poblano was excellent

A seared salmon fillet with a golden crust over creamy poblano risotto with sun dried tomatoes and a grilled lemon at Casa Di Luigi.

I was looking at the chicken and the steak, but I had been traveling that week and wanted to take it a little easier, so I went with the fish. I don’t regret it at all.

The Salmone alla Poblano is seared salmon over a creamy poblano risotto with roasted poblanos and sun dried tomatoes. I loved the crust on the salmon. It was crunchy, and it was exactly what I thought I was getting. The sauce was great.

The risotto was excellent too. Sometimes risotto comes out so soft it feels like plain rice, and I don’t like that. I also don’t like it al dente. This was right in between, the perfect consistency, with just enough oil to keep everything separate.

Vika’s mushroom ravioli didn’t do it for her

Mushroom stuffed ravioli in a brown mushroom cream sauce topped with shaved Parmesan and parsley at Casa Di Luigi.

Vika ordered the Ravioli ai Funghi, homemade ravioli stuffed with wild mushroom in a mushroom cream sauce. It came with five ravioli, and they were not small.

But she didn’t think the dish justified what it cost. There was nothing special about the mushrooms. They seemed like regular white or brown mushrooms, and nothing about the flavor made her think they were extraordinary. The sauce was okay, but it didn’t have a lot of flavor, and she ended up adding pepper. She could see pieces of garlic in it, but she didn’t really taste them.

Her words: she enjoyed her meal for what it was, and she was unimpressed. It was also heavy, which makes sense with pasta in a cream sauce.

For what it’s worth, I don’t think she ordered wrong. I just wouldn’t have ordered ravioli. I rarely order ravioli, or pasta in general, these days. If anything, I would split something like that as an appetizer, have a couple of pieces each, and then move on to the main. Vika wanted to try it, and that’s fair. Everything at our table was presented nicely, hers included.

Would we go back to Casa Di Luigi?

This is where Vika and I don’t agree.

I would go back. Not out of my way, and I’m not going to wake up and think we need to go back there because it was so good. But there are places where I leave thinking I would never come back, and I don’t feel that way about this one. My office used to be just down the road, and if it still were, I could see myself stopping in again. And if somebody told me they would be in Rolling Meadows and asked if I knew a good Italian place nearby, I would tell them about Casa Di Luigi. It isn’t bad. It’s decent, and it’s tasty.

I also think it works for a quicker, more casual date. Not a fancy, let’s get dressed up kind of date night, more of a, hey, let’s grab dinner, just the two of us.

Vika pushed back on that. She said that even for a quicker date night, quite a few other places would come to mind before this one. Nothing on the menu made her think she really wanted to come back and try it. It just didn’t do it for her.

Would we bring Josh and Emily?

Maybe. It wouldn’t be our first pick for a family dinner with Josh and Emily, but I wouldn’t rule it out either.

What dinner at Casa Di Luigi cost

An itemized Casa Di Luigi receipt listing the burrata, salmon, ravioli, a Negroni, an old fashioned and a Cannonball Merlot, with separate cash and card totals.

The crispy fried burrata was $18.99. My Salmone alla Poblano was $33.50, and Vika’s ravioli was $25.50.

On the drinks, my Negroni and Vika’s old fashioned were $14.50 each, and my Cannonball Merlot was $11.50.

That came to a $118.49 subtotal plus $14.43 in tax. The receipt prints two totals: a little over $130 if you pay with cash, and a little under $140 on a card. The focaccia and hummus were not on the check.

Casa Di Luigi location, hours and reservations

A printed hours of operation sign taped inside the Casa Di Luigi door, with a Nextdoor Fave winner sticker below it.

Address. 5500 New Wilke Road, Rolling Meadows, Illinois 60008.
Phone. (224) 735-2338.
Hours. Monday through Thursday 4:00 pm to 9:00 pm, Friday and Saturday 11:00 am to 10:00 pm, closed Sunday.
Reservations. The sign on the door says to book on Resy or call. They also take private events.
Parking. Their own lot, right out front.

The hours are from the sign on their front door. The listings we saw online show different hours, so I would go by the door, or call ahead.

Do you need a reservation at Casa Di Luigi?

We went early on a Friday evening, and the room was quiet when we got there. If you’re going later on a weekend, I would book ahead to be safe. The sign on their door says to book on Resy or call (224) 735-2338.

Is Casa Di Luigi open on Sundays?

No. Per the hours sign on their front door, they are closed Sundays. They open at 4:00 pm Monday through Thursday and at 11:00 am on Friday and Saturday.

Is Casa Di Luigi good for a date night?

For a casual date night, I think so. The cocktails are good, our waitress was lovely, and the fried burrata is a fun thing to share. If you’re looking for a dressed up, special occasion room, I don’t think this is it, and Vika would tell you there are other places she would pick first.

What should you order at Casa Di Luigi?

Based on our dinner, start with the crispy fried burrata and a cocktail, and I would point you to the Salmone alla Poblano for an entree. The one we would skip next time is the mushroom ravioli.

How much is dinner for two at Casa Di Luigi?

Our dinner for two, one appetizer, two entrees, two cocktails and a glass of wine, came to a little over $130 paying cash, or a little under $140 on a card, including tax. That works out to roughly $65 to $70 a person.

More from the northwest suburbs: Lago in Lake Zurich, Sophia Steak in Lake Forest, Foxtail on the Lake in Des Plaines and Osaka Sushi in Mundelein.

This article isn’t sponsored. Nothing was comped by the restaurant, and we didn’t tell them we were going to write about them. The focaccia and hummus they bring to the table were not on our check, and every price here comes from our itemized receipt.

#Casa Di Luigi #chicago suburbs #Cocktails #date night #Italian #Northwest Suburbs #Pasta #Rolling Meadows
Want more reviews like this one?Add Travel and Food Guy as a preferred source on Google and our new guides show up first when you plan a trip.

Alex Ostrovsky

Alex Ostrovsky is a frequent flyer, family man, and creator of Travel and Food Guy. Based in the Chicago suburbs, he travels the world with his wife Vika and their kids Josh and Emily, reviewing cruises, airline lounges, hotels, and restaurants from a real family traveler's point of view.

Leave a comment